SCOTUS Brief Calls Part of the 2A ‘Extinct’

in News

Estimated reading time: 5 minutes

Every now and then, a Supreme Court filing comes along that makes you stop, reread the argument and wonder if you understood it correctly the first time.

This is one of those filings.

Connecticut attorney David A. Robinson has submitted an amicus brief asking the U.S. Supreme Court to uphold bans on AR-15s and similar semiautomatic rifles. His central argument is not simply that certain rifles can be regulated. He wants the Court to declare part of the Second Amendment “extinct.”

Yes, that is the word used in the brief.

The AR-15 Case Before the Court

The filing comes in the consolidated cases of Viramontes v. Cook County and Grant v. Higgins. The cases challenge bans imposed by Cook County, Illinois, and Connecticut.

The question before the Supreme Court is straightforward: Do the Second and Fourteenth Amendments protect the right to possess AR-15-platform rifles and similar semiautomatic firearms?

The Court granted review on June 30, consolidated the two cases and scheduled oral arguments for December 2, 2026.

Robinson’s brief supports the governments defending their bans. However, an important distinction needs to be made. This is not a ruling, a government filing or the official brief from either respondent. Robinson wrote and funded it himself. As of October 27, the Supreme Court docket listed it as “submitted.”

If the Amendment Process Fails, Ask the Court?

Robinson says he previously tried to build support for a proposed 28th Amendment that would rewrite the constitutional protection for arms. He self-published a short book, purchased Amazon and Facebook ads and contacted elected officials.

The campaign went nowhere.

That failure becomes part of his argument to the Court. Robinson reasons that because Americans could not agree on new constitutional language, the justices should step in and declare which portions of the existing Second Amendment remain alive.

That is where the argument starts running backward.

The Constitution already provides a process for changing its language through Article V. If an effort to amend the Constitution fails, the original language remains in effect. Failure to persuade the public does not normally create permission for judges to rewrite the provision themselves.

Robinson nevertheless asks the Court to declare the militia clause “extinct.” He then argues that the protection for keeping and bearing arms should survive only to the extent judges consider a weapon necessary for personal defense or hunting.

That turns an explicit constitutional limit on government into a government-approved list of permitted purposes.

The Brief Takes Some Wild Turns

Robinson compares the Second Amendment’s militia language to Major League Baseball’s pre-1947 exclusion of Black players. He claims both concepts may have made sense to people in their respective eras but are now outdated.

He also compares firearm-capacity limits to speed limits on cars.

That analogy skips over a fairly important detail. Driving at a particular speed is not an enumerated constitutional right. The right to keep and bear arms is.

The filing goes further by suggesting that AR-15 owners who cite protection against tyranny must believe they have the right to shoot police officers attempting to enforce a firearm ban. Robinson describes gun owners as combining a “1791 mentality” with a modern AR-15.

SEE ALSO: Survey: Red-Flag Laws May Deter Gun Owners From Help

That is a massive leap from opposing government overreach to advocating violence against individual officers. It substitutes an extreme hypothetical for the actual question before the Court: whether commonly owned semiautomatic rifles fall within the protection of the Second Amendment.

The brief concludes with an imaginary conversation between a 9-year-old student and her teacher during an active-shooter drill. Robinson says the hypothetical conversation “proves” semiautomatic rifles are not constitutionally protected.

It may illustrate his policy concerns, but an invented conversation is not historical evidence or constitutional analysis.

The Argument Collides With Heller

The biggest problem is that Robinson’s “extinct militia” theory runs directly into District of Columbia v. Heller.

In Heller, the Supreme Court held that the Second Amendment protects an individual right that is not dependent on service in a militia. The Court also explained that the amendment’s prefatory clause announces a purpose but “does not limit or expand the scope” of its operative guarantee.

Robinson quotes Heller’s statement that courts cannot pronounce the Second Amendment extinct, but then asks the Court to do essentially that.

His claim that the militia no longer exists is also hard to square with current law. Federal law still recognizes both an organized militia and an unorganized militia. Whether that statute resolves the AR-15 question is another matter, but it certainly complicates the claim that the militia has simply vanished.

Robinson also argues that because Garland v. Cargill did not decide whether bump stocks receive Second Amendment protection, semiautomatic rifles may be banned. But Cargill addressed whether a bump-stock-equipped rifle qualified as a machine gun under federal statutory language. The Court’s decision not to reach a separate constitutional question did not answer it against gun owners.

Why This Brief Is Getting Attention

The filing probably will not become the central argument in these cases. It is one independently submitted amicus brief among dozens, and it does not speak for Cook County, Connecticut or the Supreme Court.

Still, it puts a remarkably blunt version of the anti-AR argument into the official record.

The Constitution is too old. The militia is obsolete. Modern rifles are too effective. The amendment process failed. Therefore, judges should declare part of the Second Amendment dead and let governments decide which arms citizens really need.

For gun owners, that sequence is exactly why constitutional protections exist in the first place.

What do you think? Is this brief simply an outlier, or does it say the quiet part out loud about the broader effort to remove AR-15s from Second Amendment protection?

*** Buy and Sell on GunsAmerica! ***

https://gunsamerica.com/listings/search

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Rodney Ford November 2, 2026, 7:54 am

    When will these liberal people ever learn that the second amendment is here to stay. An attorney, a local judge, a federal judge, even the supreme court cannot just throw out an amendment to the constitutional law. It must be ratified by three fourth of the states. They do not and I believe will never have the votes to do so. The supreme court will always throw out such ridiculous briefs. I would hope that one day, the supreme court will throw out all of the unconstitutional laws of some states so that we can all be free again.

  • dacian November 1, 2026, 4:55 pm

    During the late 1700’s in the Southern States slaves actually outnumbered Whites by 20 to 1. The Southern States wanted a guarantee that if they joined the Federal Government they would retain the right to have and control their own Militias to hunt down and kill any slaves that revolted. At the time there was a slave revolt going on in Haiti and many White Slave Owners were fleeing Haiti and bringing some of their slaves with them to the U.S. and the U,S. Slaves were finding out quickly about this. Madison then wrote the Second Amendment to entice the Southern States into joining the Union.

    Both University professors Carl T. Bogus and Carol Anderson wrote books on this subject and both came to the same conclusion and that was that the Second Amendment had zero to do with the right of the individual to keep and bear arms. It was written to guarantee mass murder during any slave revolt by hunter, killer Militias.

    Now lets compare Germany and the U,S. Germany has 25% more police than the U.S. does and Germany requires that police get 3 years of intensive training before being allowed to carry a firearm as a certified police officer. Germany also has strict gun laws as compared to the U,S. where even a raving and ranting lunatic can buy all the “second hand” guns he wats no questions asked.

    Germany vs United States — Crime Statistics Comparison
    The United States has significantly higher rates of violent crime, homicide, and recorded sexual assaults than Germany, despite Germany’s higher per‑capita gun ownership.

    Germany v/s the United States The Difference:

    Guns per 100 residents 30.3 88.8
    USA has ~3× more

    Intentional homicide rate (per 100,000) 0.81 4.70
    USA ~6× higher

    Murder rate (per 100,000) 690 cases 12,996 cases
    USA ~19× higher

    Murder rate per million people 8.44 42.01
    USA ~5× higher

    Recorded rapes (per million people) 94.45 274.04
    USA ~3× higher

    Homicide: The U.S. homicide rate is about six times Germany’s, with over 12,000 murders annually vs. ~690 in Germany

    .Gun ownership: Germany has more guns per capita (30.3 vs. 88.8), yet far fewer homicides, suggesting differences in gun use, enforcement, and societal factors

    Germany also has National Health Care with 6 different teers of Health Care. You can even opt out of it all together and rely on private insurance.

    Only 3% of the gun owners in America own 90% of all the guns. It is this Paranoid Far Right Group that is also inflamed by the NRA who gets most of its money from them that prevent any sane gun laws from ever being passed.

    In fact the majority of gun owners agree that the gun problem in the U.S. is totally out of control. When a Nation ignores mass school shooting and cares nothing about the lives of their children it is a Nation well on its way to total societal disintegration, In fact on average 45,000 people are gunned down in the U.S. every year. No other civilized industrialized Nation on earth permits such utter and total madness.

    .

    ↩ ∞

    • Brian November 2, 2026, 8:26 pm

      45,000 people are NOT gunned down in the U.S. every year. Check your info… I didn’t try looking up the rest since you were way off on the 45K.

  • Dale November 1, 2026, 12:10 pm

    With the population of the U.S. exceeding over 300 million, only one person wants to rewrite The constitution. I don’t see that happening.

  • Dit October 31, 2026, 5:11 pm

    All this would stop if you were required to pay $100 million ever time you file this idiocy. The other solutions to just stop issuing guns to Democrats.

  • Costas Gregorio October 30, 2026, 4:17 pm

    Is this the same guy that defaced the 911 memorial? Or from the same fringe?

  • LYLE A KNOX October 30, 2026, 1:38 pm

    Obviously, this attorney has never heard of Article 5 on changing the Constitution.

  • Joe Salpuccinelli October 30, 2026, 1:12 pm

    Gun banners are incrementalists. If left to their own devices, they would eventually ban activities such as baseball, football, hockey, basketball, golf, horseshoes, and the Olympic events of archery, discus, shotput, & javelin because they involve the use of a “projectile.”

  • Joe Salpuccinelli October 30, 2026, 1:10 pm

    Gun banners are incrementalists. If left to their own devices, they would eventually ban activities such as baseball, football, hockey, basketball, golf, horseshoes, and the Olympic events of archery, discus, shotput, & javelin because they involve the use of a “projectile.”

  • Bozz October 30, 2026, 12:30 pm

    When the Founding Fathers wrote the Second Amendment, they had not just returned from a hunting trip, they had just liberated a nation.

    • GomeznSA October 30, 2026, 8:23 pm

      Yep – the 2nd specifically says “arms” and Does Not Place ANY Limits on them, regardless of what ‘modern revisionists’ “believe” or want. Period.

    • Kane October 31, 2026, 9:45 pm

      lolololol- Great point.

  • George H Steele October 30, 2026, 11:55 am

    Ignorance on display regarding exactly WHAT the Constitution and Bill of Rights ARE. They are limited permission slips that apply to the government that we constructed to serve us. “You may do these things, but only within these limits”.

    The government may be big, but the people are bigger. The government may have delegated authority, but the authority of the people is absolute. The Second Amendment is not a license to The People; it is a requirement placed ON the government BY the people – that it may NOT INFRINGE on the intrinsic right to bear arms, in carrying out the duties we assign it.

    The Constitution is a RULE BOOK for the government, and does not bind The People – it binds our employees. If they can’t follow the rules in the process of doing their job, they’re FIRED.

    Unfortunately, the firing procedure is the voting booth – but that’s intentional, to put brakes on the passions of a democratic society and slow mob-like behavior down, to minimize damage and promote stability – even though there are times when we all would like to send them a pink slip that says: “You are an idiot; clean out your desk today.”

  • lewis bolman October 30, 2026, 9:27 am

    Funny that the ar platform really didn’t become popular until they banded it. Before there were only a few manufacturers, colt neutered the preban sporter like bitches
    I don’t buy their stuff since, I got a half torn bolt carrier from that mess, that was doing damage to my expensive rifle.

  • 2WarAbnVet October 30, 2026, 9:15 am

    In writing the Second Amendment the Founders had no thought of hunting or self-protection in mind …

    “We bear arms to keep from becoming enslaved by the federal government AND to protect ourselves from the tyranny of OUR REPRESENTATIVES, whose dereliction leads us to suffer the same fate of foreign nations.” – George Mason

    “Their swords, and every other terrible implement of the soldier, are the birthright of an American. … [T]he unlimited power of the sword is not in the hands of either the federal or state governments, but, where I trust in God it will ever remain, in the hands of the people.” – Tench Coxe, Delegate for Pennsylvania to the Continental Congress, ThePennsylvania Gazette, Feb. 20, 1788

    For a people who are free, and who mean to remain so, a well-organized and armed militia is their best security. – Thomas Jefferson

    “The defense of one’s self, justly called the primary law of nature, is not, nor can it be abrogated by any regulation of municipal law. This principle of defense is not confined merely to the person; it extends to the liberty and the property of a man … it extends to the person of every one, who is in danger; perhaps, to the liberty of every one, whose liberty is unjustly and forcibly attacked.” —James Wilson (1791)

  • Wapitihunter October 30, 2026, 9:05 am

    The 2A is not outdated. It was included to protect against a tyrannical government and enemies, both foreign and domestic. There is something very wrong with Robinson’s thinking. With the invasion of the millions of illegals, Muslims, and other terrorists. There is no better time for the right to keep and bear arms than now. When an illegal can get himself elected President and divide this nation and allow another illegal to get elected to Congress, then a Pinocchio Joe with an auto pen gets illegally elected to the Presidency. It would appear that things are getting pretty tyrannical. If or rather when the terrorist decide to attack, Joe O’Biden’s grandpa’s double barrel shotgun will be no match for the AK-47 and ARs that the terrorist brought with them. Holderand Killery Clinton “lost” over 100 ARs to the Mexican Cartels during operation Fast and Furious. The Demoncrat Cartel would like nothing better than ro remove the firearms that would give us a fighting chance against enemies both foreign and domestic. Ohomo and Omar or whatever her name is are currently under investigation.

  • James S October 30, 2026, 8:43 am

    This whatever written by a doofus is a prime example of the saying, “if you can’t dazzle them with brilliance, baffle em with bullshit.”

    My two cents,

    Connecticut attorney David A. Robinson makes a brilliant argument for getting rid of the 13th Amendment.

    Using his argument the country needed the 13th Amendment because in the beginning slavery was legal in America .

    Now in modern America slavery does not exist, ipso facto we no longer need the 13th Amendment so let’s do away with it…

    WHAT COULD POSSIBLY GO WRONG??

  • James S October 30, 2026, 8:42 am

    This whatever written by a doofus is a prime example of the saying, “if you can’t dazzle them with brilliance, baffle em with bullshit.

    My two cents,

    Connecticut attorney David A. Robinson makes a brilliant argument for getting rid of the 13th Amendment.

    Using his argument the country needed the 13th Amendment because in the beginning slavery was legal in America .

    Now in modern America slavery does not exist, ipso facto we no longer need the 13th Amendment so let’s do away with it…

    WHAT COULD POSSIBLY GO WRONG??

  • paul I'll call you what I want/1st Amendment October 27, 2026, 7:42 pm

    i hope they laugh his case to the trash can, and then try him for treason!