Florida AG Says This Ban Is Unconstitutional

in News

Estimated reading time: 2 minutes

Florida’s attorney general says the state’s bump stock ban violates the Second Amendment. His office won’t defend convictions under it.

So, did Florida just get rid of the ban? No.

And as Colion Noir explains in his breakdown, that gap between what the attorney general says and what the law still says is the part Florida gun owners need to pay attention to.

Start with the name. “Bump stock ban” sounds like a law about one specific accessory. But Florida Statute § 790.222 also reaches devices used to make a semiautomatic firearm fire faster than a person could fire it unassisted.

It doesn’t name forced-reset triggers, but that broad wording is exactly why they came up in the debate.

Attorney General James Uthmeier warned that the law, as written, appears to sweep in trigger enhancements people use for lawful purposes. A violation is a third-degree felony.

That’s where Noir connects the dots to Rare Breed Triggers. In 2024, a federal judge in Texas rejected ATF’s classification of the forced-reset triggers at issue as machine guns under federal law.

SEE ALSO: Shot in the Head, Then He Never Slept Again

The Justice Department settled with Rare Breed in May 2025. Uthmeier cites the Texas case in his Nov. 13 opinion. The distinction matters: The Texas case dealt with federal law. It didn’t decide whether Florida’s separate ban was constitutional.

Noir also zeroes in on the politics. Republican Gov. Rick Scott signed the ban in 2018 as part of a broader package after the Parkland shooting, saying everyone had to give a little.

Eight years later, a Republican attorney general answered that argument directly: “The Constitution, however, brooks little compromise when it comes to citizens’ fundamental rights.” For Noir, the point is that a Republican signature doesn’t make a gun restriction any less deserving of scrutiny.

Here’s the catch: The attorney general’s own office says its opinions don’t bind courts. A promise not to defend a conviction isn’t an order barring local prosecutors from bringing charges, and it doesn’t erase the statute.

Florida lawmakers had a chance to do that this year. HB 6021, which would have repealed the ban outright, died in a House subcommittee in March.

That leaves Florida with a felony statute its own attorney general says the state can’t lawfully enforce.

Should lawmakers repeal the ban outright, or would you rather see a court settle the constitutional question?

*** Buy and Sell on GunsAmerica! ***

https://gunsamerica.com/listings/search

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *