Mamdani Replaces Cops: Will It Work?

in News

Estimated reading time: 3 minutes

You don’t need a counterterrorism unit to talk to people holding signs. But if a protest turns violent, you need more than somebody with a bullhorn.

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is betting the city can do both jobs better by separating them. The question is how well that split holds up when a peaceful crowd turns into something police actually need to deal with.

On Nov. 16, Mamdani and Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch announced they’re disbanding the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group, or SRG. It handled both crowd management and counterterrorism.

The new civilian Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division will help prepare for protests and communicate with demonstrators. Its members won’t carry weapons or have arrest powers.

That’s the part Harris Faulkner and retired NYPD inspector Paul Mauro seized on in their Fox News segment. Mauro argued that the city is giving up a trained, coordinated unit that could respond when a demonstration sprang up with little warning.

Fair question: What happens when talking isn’t enough? But the plan doesn’t put civilians in charge of arrests or send them out to handle terrorist threats.

The NYPD will still have a 30-officer First Amendment Support Team (is that enough manpower?), which will handle dialogue while the civilian division gets up and running.

A separate Patrol Support Division will handle crowd management and make arrests when necessary. And the old unit’s counterterrorism duties are staying with the NYPD, under its Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau.

So the administration would argue that this is a reshuffle of who does what, not a withdrawal of police from protests.

There’s a good reason to want a lighter touch at peaceful demonstrations (“peaceful” being the operative word. Not “mostly peaceful” which is something different altogether if you can recall). If you’ve ever rallied against a gun bill, you probably don’t want City Hall treating a crowd of gun-rights supporters like a security threat just because it’s loud.

New York already agreed to change how it polices protests after litigation over its response to the 2020 demonstrations. The new plan formalizes restrictions on tactics like kettling—boxing in a crowd—and using tear gas or long guns for crowd management.

Can it work?

I’m skeptical of anything a socialist does but, in fairness, time will tell.

The numbers worth watching are injuries, use-of-force complaints, and how long it takes officers to intervene when violence breaks out—not just how many arrests the city makes.

What do you think? Will this “reshuffling” work?

*** Buy and Sell on GunsAmerica! ***

https://gunsamerica.com/listings/search

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *