The .22 Magnum looks like the obvious upgrade. Longer case, heavier bullet, more speed, more energy. Then you pay for a box and see the price, and you start wondering whether the 22 WMR vs 22 LR question is really as simple as bigger is better. It is not, and our own testing proves it cuts both ways.
On the hunting and varmint side, the magnum earns its money. The .22 WMR throws a 30 to 40 grain bullet much faster than a .22 LR, which turns a plinker into a capable varmint gun out to 100 yards and more. Brian McCombie’s chronograph showed the difference plainly: Federal Punch .22 WMR left his Walther WMP at 1,326 fps with 176 ft-lb of energy, while Punch .22 LR left a Browning Buck Mark at 1,313 fps with 111 ft-lb.
On the defense side, the story flips. Rob Garrett shot three .22 WMR defensive loads from a Smith & Wesson 351C J-frame into gel. All three expanded in bare gel and none expanded behind four layers of denim. Federal Punch .22 LR from the matching 43C actually penetrated deeper. His pick, if he could own only one, was the cheaper .22 LR revolver.
So here is where I land. For rodents, varmints, and anything you want to drop at 100 yards, buy the .22 WMR. For squirrels, cheap practice, and a light revolver you will actually shoot a lot, buy the .22 LR. Our best .22 Magnum guns guide covers the magnum rifles and pistols we have tested.
Table of contents
Buyer’s Guide: 22 WMR vs 22 LR
They Are Not Interchangeable
The .22 WMR, or .22 Winchester Magnum Rimfire, was introduced in 1959 and uses a longer, larger rimfire case than the .22 LR. Despite the shared .22 name, the two need separate chambers. A revolver or rifle has to be built or fitted for the cartridge you feed it.
Velocity and Energy
McCombie’s numbers are the cleanest comparison we have. Federal Punch .22 WMR with a 45 grain jacketed hollow point: 1,326 fps and 176 ft-lb from the WMP. Federal Punch .22 LR with a 29 grain bullet: 1,313 fps and 111 ft-lb from a Buck Mark with a 5 7/8 inch barrel. Winchester’s 37 grain Silvertip .22 LR: 1,117 fps and 103 ft-lb. The magnum carries far more energy because it moves a heavier bullet at the same or higher speed. He also noted Federal rates its .380 ACP Punch at 180 ft-lb, not far above the magnum rimfire.
Barrel Length Matters More for the Magnum
Our .22 Magnum guide makes the point that velocity climbs with barrel length, so a rifle gets the most out of the cartridge. Garrett’s short-barrel J-frames showed the other end of that curve: his three WMR defense loads averaged 1,018 to 1,080 fps, while .22 LR Punch averaged 1,203 fps from the same size revolver.
Penetration and Expansion
Garrett used Clear Ballistics 10 percent synthetic gel at 10 feet, bare and behind four layers of denim, against an FBI benchmark of 12 to 18 inches. Federal Punch .22 LR averaged 15.13 inches bare and 14.33 through denim. The three .22 WMR loads averaged 11.76 to 12.48 inches bare and about 11 to 12 inches through denim, and none expanded behind denim. He concluded the denim slowed the magnum bullets below the speed they needed to open.
Cost and Practice
This is a big one. Federal lists Punch .22 LR at $11.99 per 50 and Punch .22 WMR at $27.99 per 50, both MSRP in 2026, and CCI Mini-Mag .22 LR hollow points at $12.99 per 100. The magnum costs more than twice as much, and it is louder with more muzzle flash and felt recoil.
Reliability in Semi-Autos
The .22 WMR is a long rimfire case, and semi-autos can be picky. Our PMR-30 reviewer had his best results with Hornady 30 grain V-Max, while a Bear Creek Arsenal BC-202 rifle had feeding and firing problems early in testing. Revolvers and lever guns remove most of that risk. The .22 LR has its own quirk: plain lead bullets mean Garrett’s 43C needed cleaning more often than the magnum revolver.
.22 WMR: Best for Varmints and Rodent Control (2026)
The magnum is the rimfire you buy when a .22 LR feels light for the animal. It hits harder and carries more energy downrange, and McCombie notes it has been a useful round for small game hunting, rodent control, and plinking since 1959. McCombie put more than 250 rounds through the optics-ready Walther WMP, drilled a 0.40 inch five-shot group at 12 yards from a rest with Winchester 40 grain varmint ammo, and called it a fine choice for plinking, small game, and varmint hunting. It holds 15+1.
Read our full Walther WMP .22 WMR review here.
Key Specs
- Introduced: 1959
- Typical Bullet Weights: 30 to 45 grain
- Example Load: Federal Punch 45 grain, 1,326 fps and 176 ft-lb from a Walther WMP
- Practical Varmint Range: Out to about 100 yards and more from a rifle
- Ammo Cost: Federal Punch $27.99 per 50, MSRP (2026)
- Guns: Rifles, lever actions, revolvers, and a few semi-auto pistols
Pros
- Far more energy than .22 LR
- Capable varmint gun out to 100 yards and more
- More loads designed for personal defense
- Jacketed bullets keep guns cleaner
Cons
- More than twice the price per round
- Louder, with more flash and recoil
- Semi-autos can be ammo sensitive
- Loses much of its edge in short barrels
🛒 Check Current Price for .22 WMR Guns on GunsAmerica

.22 LR: Best for Practice, Small Game and Light Revolvers (2026)
The .22 LR is still the most useful rimfire most people will ever own. It is cheap, quiet, and runs in every kind of gun, and our best .22 LR rifles guide covers everything from 10/22s to precision trainers. Garrett’s gel test gave it a surprising win on defense, too: Federal Punch .22 LR averaged 15.13 inches of penetration in bare gel from a lightweight J-frame, deeper than any magnum load he tested. His conclusion was blunt. If he could own only one, he would take the 43C in .22 LR with Federal Punch, for penetration, low cost, and wide availability.
Read our full .22 Magnum vs .22 LR gel test here.
Key Specs
- Typical Bullet Weights: 29 to 40 grain
- Example Load: Federal Punch 29 grain, 1,313 fps and 111 ft-lb from a Browning Buck Mark
- Gel Result: Federal Punch averaged 15.13 inches bare, 14.33 through denim (S&W 43C)
- Ammo Cost: Federal Punch $11.99 per 50; CCI Mini-Mag HP $12.99 per 100, MSRP (2026)
- Test Revolver: S&W 43C, eight shots, 11.5 ounces, $799 MSRP (2026)
Pros
- Among the cheapest ammo there is to practice with
- Quiet and very low recoil
- Huge selection of rifles, pistols, and revolvers
- Punch .22 LR penetrated deepest in our revolver test
Cons
- Much less energy for varmints at distance
- Lead bullets mean more cleaning
- Light bullet for anything bigger than small game
🛒 Check Current Price for .22 LR Rifles on GunsAmerica

22 WMR vs 22 LR: Head to Head
- Energy and varmint range: .22 WMR.
- Cost to shoot: .22 LR, by more than half.
- Noise and recoil: .22 LR.
- Penetration from a short J-frame in our gel test: .22 LR with Federal Punch.
- Defensive load selection: .22 WMR.
- Gun selection: .22 LR.
A Word on Rimfire Defense
Garrett said it straight, and I agree: either rimfire is a compromise next to a centerfire. A .22 you shoot well beats a bigger gun you cannot run, and light rimfire revolvers suit some shooters with limited hand strength. But if you can handle a centerfire, that is the stronger choice. Our best .22 revolvers guide covers the rimfire wheelguns we have tested if that is still your path.
Which Should You Buy?
The 22 WMR vs 22 LR decision comes down to the job. If you shoot varmints and pests, or want a rimfire that reaches 100 yards with authority, the .22 WMR is worth every extra cent. A rifle makes the most of it.
For squirrels, training, plinking with the kids, and a lightweight revolver you will practice with often, buy the .22 LR. Our best .22 LR rifles guide is the place to shop. Plenty of us end up owning both, and that is not a bad problem to have. GunsAmerica.com has thousands of rimfires in both calibers.
