Benelli M2 vs M4 used to be an easy fight to explain. The M2 was the light, clean-running inertia gun. The M4 was the gas-operated combat shotgun the Marines picked and the military calls the M1014. Then Benelli went and put a gas system in a gun with M2 on the side. Thanks, guys.
So now there are really three shotguns hiding inside this search: the classic inertia M2, the brand-new gas-operated M2-G1, and the M4. We have range time on all three. Clay Martin ran an inertia M2 wearing a 26-round XRail tube and reported zero malfunctions with birdshot, buckshot, slugs, and whatever else was lying around his house. Travis Pike has more than 1,500 rounds through his M4. True Pearce tested the factory 7+1 M4 EXT in 2025, and Mitchell Graf fed the M2-G1 rusty, water-damaged shells in 2026 without a single malfunction.
Here is the blunt answer up front. The M4 is the proven gas gun, and it costs like a proven gas gun. The M2-G1 is the interesting new kid with a rear piston system and a much lower starting price. The classic inertia M2 is the lightweight option that runs clean, though Benelli’s tactical lineup now leads with the M2-G1, so check what is actually on the shelf.
The buyer’s guide comes first, then each shotgun with specs, pros, cons, and what our reviewers saw. If you want to see where these sit in the whole Benelli family, our best Benelli guns guide ranks the line from field guns to rifles.
Table of contents
Buyer’s Guide: Benelli M2 vs M4
Inertia vs ARGO vs R.P.O.
The classic M2 is inertia driven. The gun recoils, the bolt body stays put for a split second, a spring stores the energy, and the action cycles. Few parts, little fouling, but it does not bleed off gas, so it can kick harder. The M4 uses ARGO, Benelli’s auto-regulating gas system with two short-stroke pistons near the chamber where the gas is hotter and cleaner. The M2-G1 uses the new Rear Piston Operated system, which moves dual short-stroke pistons even closer to the chamber and tucks the recoil spring in the stock, away from carbon.
Adding Weight
This is the old knock on inertia guns. Pike wrote that adding weight to an inertia Benelli can affect reliability, which is part of why the military wanted a gas gun it could hang lights and optics on. Clay’s XRail M2 is an interesting counterpoint: it weighed 9 pounds empty and 11.4 loaded and still ran everything he fed it, though XRail advised premium shells in the 1,235 to 1,300 fps range.
Ammo Sensitivity
No semi-auto shotgun loves featherweight target loads. Pearce’s M4 EXT would not cycle 980 fps light birdshot. Pike’s M4 fed and ejected 950 fps trap loads about half the time. Benelli told Graf it recommends 1-1/8 ounce or heavier field loads at 1,200 fps or more for its 12 gauge semi-autos, plus a 50-round break-in with high brass.
Capacity and Stocks
Older imported M4s came with a five-round tube and fixed stock to stay legal under import rules, and Pike installed four U.S. parts to add a seven-round tube and the collapsing stock. The M4 EXT fixes that from the factory with a 7+1 tube and a five-position stock. The M2-G1 Graf tested had a collapsible stock that drops as it extends, which changes your cheek weld from position to position.
Price
The M4 EXT listed at $2,599 MSRP when Pearce reviewed it in November 2025. Our August 2026 launch coverage put the M2-G1 at a $1,829 starting MSRP. We do not have a current classic M2 Tactical price from our own coverage, and its production status is unconfirmed.
Benelli M4: Best for Proven Duty Reliability (2026)
The M4 has the resume. Pike calls it one of the most competent fighting shotguns on the planet, and he has the round count to say it: over 1,500 shells, choking only on the lightest loads. With standard buckshot he found it stupid easy to run double taps, and the trigger was crisper than any shotgun needs. His one real gripe was the tiny bolt release. Pearce’s M4 EXT fixed exactly that with an oversized release, then added a factory 7+1 tube and a five-position stock. After one stumble on its very first ghost-loaded round, the EXT ran bird, buck, and slugs without another malfunction, and Pearce never added a drop of oil.
Read our full Benelli M4 EXT review here, and Pike’s long-term Benelli M4 range report.
Key Specs
- Gauge: 12 gauge, 2-3/4 and 3 inch
- Capacity: 7+1 (M4 EXT), nine with a ghost load
- Weight: 8.4 pounds average (M4 EXT)
- Barrel: 18.5 inches
- Action: ARGO gas, dual short-stroke pistons, rotating bolt
- Sights / Optic: Adjustable ghost ring rear, protected front post, Picatinny rail
- Price: $2,599 MSRP (M4 EXT, November 2025)
Pros
- Military-adopted ARGO system with a long track record
- Over 1,500 rounds in Pike’s gun with problems only on very light loads
- M4 EXT adds 7+1, a five-position stock, and a bigger bolt release
- One pin drops the trigger group for cleaning
Cons
- The priciest gun here by a wide margin
- Pearce wanted a bigger charging handle and a beveled loading port
- Older imported M4s need U.S. parts for a longer tube and collapsing stock
🛒 Check Current Price for Benelli M4 on GunsAmerica

Benelli M2-G1: Best New Gas Gun for the Money (2026)
Graf went out of his way to make the M2-G1 fail. Cheap birdshot. Rusty shells that had been water damaged. Suppressed strings with a JK Armament 195 SGX. Roughly 100 rounds dumped as fast as he could reload. It never malfunctioned over several hundred rounds. On the timer he saw splits as low as 0.10 second, averaged about 0.13, and emptied all eight rounds in 1.02 seconds. The handguard got hot but stayed holdable barehanded. He is not in love with everything: the pistol grip angle is steep, the stock geometry fights your cheek weld, and the gun ships with a modified choke even though Benelli recommends cylinder or improved cylinder for slugs.
Read our full Benelli M2-G1 review here, and our M2-G1 launch coverage for configurations.
Key Specs
- Gauge: 12 gauge
- Capacity: Eight rounds total in Graf’s timed string
- Weight: Not listed in our review
- Choke: Flush-fit modified Mobil choke included
- Action: R.P.O. gas, dual short-stroke rear pistons, recoil spring in the stock
- Sights / Optic: Ghost rings, top Picatinny rail, M-LOK, steel QD sockets
- Price: $1,829 starting MSRP (August 2026 launch coverage)
Pros
- Zero malfunctions, including rusty, water-damaged shells
- Flat recoil and 0.10 second splits on Graf’s timer
- Runs cleaner by design, with the recoil spring isolated from fouling
- Steel QD inserts and a clean M-LOK handguard
- Much cheaper than an M4 at launch pricing
Cons
- Brand-new system with no long-term track record yet
- Ships with a modified choke, not slug-ready from the box
- Collapsible stock changes cheek weld between positions
🛒 Check Current Price for Benelli M2-G1 on GunsAmerica

Classic Benelli M2: Best for Light Weight and Clean Running (2026)
The inertia M2 earned its reputation in 3-gun, where shotguns go to die. Clay wrote that the M2 has proven to be one of the most reliable semi-auto shotguns around, if not the most reliable. In his review of Beretta’s 1301 Tactical he even described the 1301 as the gun that finally unseated the ubiquitous Benelli M2 for the reliability title in competition. That is a compliment to both. His RCI XRail M2 ran Federal target loads, buckshot, slugs, and random 12 gauge with zero malfunctions, and the extra weight made it a flat shooter.
Read our Benelli M2 XRail review here. Note that it covers the M2 with RCI’s integrated 26-round system, not a stock M2 Tactical.
Key Specs
- Gauge: 12 gauge
- Capacity: 25+1 or 24+1 (RCI XRail version tested)
- Weight: 9 pounds empty, 11.4 loaded (XRail version)
- Barrel / Length: 21 inches / 42.5 inches (XRail version)
- Action: Inertia driven
- Sights / Optic: Varies by configuration
- Price: Not quoted in our coverage; current tactical production unconfirmed
Pros
- Inertia action stays clean with few parts
- Clay’s test gun ran zero malfunctions across mixed ammo
- Long competition track record
Cons
- Inertia guns can kick harder because they do not bleed off gas
- Pike notes added weight can affect inertia reliability
- Benelli’s tactical page now leads with the M2-G1; classic M2 Tactical status unconfirmed
🛒 Check Current Price for Benelli M2 Tactical on GunsAmerica
Benelli M2 vs M4: Head to Head
- Track record: M4, by decades and a military contract.
- Speed in our testing: M2-G1, with 0.10 second splits and eight rounds in 1.02 seconds.
- Light-load tolerance: None of them love sub-1,000 fps target loads.
- Maintenance: M2-G1 and classic M2 run cleaner by design; the M4’s ARGO pistons sit near the chamber to cut fouling too.
- Price at the figures quoted above: M2-G1 is roughly $770 less than an M4 EXT.
Which Benelli Should You Buy?
Buy the M4 if the shotgun has a job and you want the one with the longest resume of doing that job. Pike’s 1,500-round gun and Pearce’s EXT both back it up, and the EXT finally ships with the capacity and stock people used to buy aftermarket.
Buy the M2-G1 if you want a modern gas gun at a lower starting price and you are comfortable being an early adopter. Graf could not make it quit, and that is the most important thing a fighting shotgun can tell you. Swap the choke before you shoot slugs.
Look for a classic inertia M2 if light weight and simplicity matter more than recoil, and confirm the configuration before you buy. Whichever you pick, run your actual carry load through it first. Our best home defense shotguns guide has more options, and GunsAmerica.com has new and used Benellis listed every day.
