.45 Colt vs .45 Long Colt is one of those questions that sounds like a trap, and the answer is refreshingly simple: they are the same cartridge. If a box says .45 Colt and your revolver says .45 Long Colt, or .45 LC, you are good to go. Nobody at the factory is playing games with you. It is one round with two names, and both have been in use for well over a century.
Our own writers use both names interchangeably. Robert Sadowski, in his look at which revolver caliber is best for concealed carry, writes “45 Long Colt, also known as the 45 Colt.” His review of the Cimarron U.S.V. Artillery calls it .45 Long Colt in one sentence and .45 Colt in the next. Taurus Judge owners know it as the cartridge that shares its rim and body with the .410 shell. Same thing every time.
So where did “Long” come from? The short version is that the Army once had two .45 revolver cartridges in the supply chain, and the Colt round was the longer of the two. The rest of this page covers that history, what the name means at the ammo counter, which cartridges are actually different and not interchangeable, and what kinds of loads and guns you will find. I will also point you to our reviews where we chronographed real .45 Colt ammo, so you know what the old round does today.
If you are shopping single actions, our best Colt revolvers guide is a good place to start.
Table of contents
Buyer’s Guide: .45 Colt vs .45 Long Colt
The Short Answer
.45 Colt, .45 Long Colt, .45 LC, and 45 Colt all describe the same rimmed, straight-walled cartridge introduced with the Colt Single Action Army in 1873. Ammunition marked any of those ways fits a gun marked any of those ways, assuming the gun is in good condition and the load is appropriate for it.
Where “Long” Came From
Smith & Wesson’s Model 3 revolver, built from 1868 to 1898, was bought in small numbers by the U.S. Army, and that version was called the Schofield after design changes by Major George W. Schofield. As Sadowski notes in his Cimarron Model 3 American review, original S&W Americans were chambered for shorter cartridges, including .45 Schofield. The commonly told story is that with both the Colt and the shorter Schofield round in service, people started calling the Colt round the “long” one to tell them apart. The nickname outlived the Schofield in Army service and stuck.
What You Will See on the Box
Most ammunition is labeled .45 Colt, and many guns and catalogs say .45 Long Colt or .45 LC. Do not overthink it. If you see .45 Colt on a box and .45 LC on a barrel, they match.
What It Is Not
Here is where people actually get in trouble. .45 ACP is a completely different, shorter, rimless pistol cartridge. Some revolvers fire both, but only because they have a second cylinder or use moon clips. The Ruger Blackhawk Rob Garrett tested came with a separate .45 ACP cylinder, and the S&W Governor uses moon clips. .454 Casull and .460 S&W are much more powerful cartridges. Trapr Swonson notes you can fire .45 Colt in a .454 Casull chamber, and both .45 Colt and .454 Casull in a .460 S&W, but never the other way around. And the .410 shotshell shares rim and body size with .45 Colt, which is why the Taurus Judge exists.
Power Levels
The original black powder load threw a 255 grain bullet at about 850 fps for roughly 409 ft-lb, per Sadowski. Today, Swonson says factory .45 Colt offerings range from mild 800 fps loads to about 1,500 fps. That is a huge spread. Cowboy action loads are deliberately soft. Hotter loads are made for strong modern revolvers and lever guns, not for old Colts or replicas. Always match the load to what the gun and the ammo maker say is safe.
Which Guns Shoot It
Single-action revolvers are the classic home of the .45 Colt: Colt SAA, the Uberti and Cimarron replicas, and the Ruger Vaquero and Blackhawk. Lever guns like the Henry Big Boy are offered in it. And .410 revolvers like the Taurus Judge fire it too, though Sadowski’s carry table notes .45 Colt defense loads end up mostly in single actions and the Judge.
.45 Colt Single-Action Revolvers: Best for Cowboy Action and Field Carry (2026)
Sadowski’s Cimarron U.S.V. Artillery, a 5.5 inch replica of the Colt Artillery Model, was properly regulated at 15 yards right out of the box. From a rest, Winchester Defender 225 grain bonded hollow points averaged slightly over 2.25 inches for six shots, and Hornady Cowboy 255 grain loads averaged 2 inches. He found the Cowboy loads mild and a hoot to shoot, and the Defender loads only slightly stiffer. For a stronger gun with more range, Garrett’s Lipsey’s Ruger Blackhawk Flattop Bisley Taffin tribute chronographed a Lost River 270 grain Keith semi-wadcutter at 936 fps with a 4.5 inch group, and a High Desert 250 grain load at 746 fps with a 4 inch group.
Read our full Cimarron U.S.V. Artillery review here, plus the Ruger Blackhawk Taffin review and the Cimarron Model 3 American review.
Key Specs
- Cartridge: .45 Colt, also called .45 Long Colt or .45 LC
- Original Load: 255 grain at about 850 fps, about 409 ft-lb (black powder)
- Modern Factory Range: About 800 to 1,500 fps
- Defense Load Example: Winchester Defender 225 grain, 850 fps / 361 ft-lb (Sadowski’s table)
- Measured: Lost River 270 grain 936 fps; High Desert 250 grain 746 fps (Ruger Blackhawk)
- Example Trigger: 2 pounds 8 ounces (Cimarron U.S.V. Artillery)
- Price: No MSRP provided in our Cimarron review
Pros
- Big, heavy bullets that do not need much velocity
- Soft cowboy loads for practice and competition
- Strong modern revolvers handle much hotter loads
- Some revolvers add a .45 ACP cylinder for cheaper practice
Cons
- Ammo is less common than 9mm or .357 Magnum
- Hot loads are not safe in older or replica revolvers
- The two names confuse new buyers
🛒 Check Current Price for .45 Colt Revolvers on GunsAmerica

.45 Colt Lever Guns and .410 Revolvers: Best for a Second Gun on the Same Ammo (2026)
A .45 Colt revolver and a .45 Colt lever gun is a classic pairing, and Henry offers its Big Boy Carbine in .45 Colt alongside .44 and .357 Magnum. Sam Trisler tested the .44 Magnum version: a 16.5 inch octagon barrel, seven rounds, and just under 2 inch groups at 100 yards with irons. On the other end of the spectrum, Paul Helinski’s 2 inch Taurus Judge Public Defender Poly pushed Hornady’s 225 grain FTX .45 Colt at 735 fps, about 200 fps slower than he says the same load runs from a rifle. That is the trade: barrel length makes a big difference with this cartridge.
Read our full Henry Big Boy Carbine review here, and our Taurus Judge ballistics test.
Key Specs
- Lever Gun Example: Henry Big Boy Carbine, offered in .45 Colt
- Barrel: 16.5 inch octagon (Big Boy Carbine)
- Capacity: 7 rounds (Big Boy Carbine)
- Revolver Example: Taurus Judge, .45 Colt and .410
- Measured: Hornady 225 grain FTX 735 fps / 266 ft-lb from a 2 inch Judge (2011)
- Price: $899.95 MSRP for the Big Boy Carbine (2016)
Pros
- One cartridge for a revolver and a rifle
- Longer barrels add real velocity
- .410 revolvers give a shotshell option
Cons
- Short-barreled .410 revolvers lose a lot of velocity
- Our Big Boy test was in .44 Magnum, not .45 Colt
- Load selection still needs care
🛒 Check Current Price for .45 Colt Lever Actions on GunsAmerica

.45 Colt vs .45 Long Colt: Quick Reference
- Same cartridge? Yes.
- Interchangeable with .45 ACP? No, unless the gun has a separate cylinder or uses moon clips.
- Fires in a .454 Casull? Yes, .45 Colt can be fired in a .454 Casull chamber.
- Fires in a .410 revolver like the Judge? Yes.
- Safe in any .45 Colt gun at any power? No. Match the load to the gun.
The Bottom Line
Buy whichever box your store has. .45 Colt and .45 Long Colt are one cartridge, and the “Long” is a leftover from the days when the Army also issued the shorter Schofield round.
What matters is power level. Use cowboy loads in replica single actions and older Colts, and save the heavy stuff for strong modern revolvers and lever guns built for it. If you want a revolver that can also shoot cheap .45 ACP, look for a convertible model like Garrett’s Blackhawk.
For more on how cartridge names and case lengths matter in revolvers, read our .38 Special vs .357 Magnum explainer. If you want a gun for cowboy matches, our top cowboy action revolvers list is a good start, and GunsAmerica.com has .45 Colt revolvers and rifles listed every day.
For how the .45 Colt stacks up against other revolver rounds, read our .357 Magnum vs .45 Colt vs .45 ACP comparison.
