Tennessee DA Rules Fatal Vape Shop Shooting Self-Defense

in News

Estimated reading time: 3 minutes

Newly released surveillance footage provides a clearer picture of a fatal confrontation outside a Tennessee vape shop and why prosecutors decided not to charge the armed man who fired the shots.

The August 14 shooting killed 24-year-old Dalton Spaulding outside the A1 Smoke and Vape Shop on Roy Martin Road in Gray. After reviewing the video and witness statements, First Judicial District Attorney General Steve Finney determined that Spaulding was the primary aggressor and that the shooter acted in self-defense.

Confrontation Captured on Video

WJHL News Channel 11 obtained the surveillance footage through a public-records request.

The video reportedly shows Spaulding entering the store and confronting 59-year-old Kevin Nottingham. Investigators said the argument started after Spaulding accused Nottingham of looking disrespectfully at his grandfather, who was waiting outside.

The verbal confrontation moved toward the doorway, where Spaulding grabbed Nottingham and violently threw him to the ground. Nottingham wore a prosthetic leg, which became detached during the takedown.

According to prosecutors, Spaulding continued attacking Nottingham while he was down.

That was when Nottingham drew a .38-caliber revolver and fired four rounds. Three struck Spaulding in the chest and arm. Spaulding died at the scene.

SEE ALSO: Colt Government Model .45: 1000 Rounds Later

Nottingham told investigators he had warned Spaulding that he had one leg and was a senior citizen. In his written statement, Nottingham said he was in pain, remained under attack and believed he had run out of options.

“When I realized I had no other choice, I pulled my pistol,” Nottingham wrote.

Prosecutors Decline Charges

Finney’s office reviewed the complete video along with multiple witness statements that reportedly supported Nottingham’s account.

The district attorney ultimately concluded that Spaulding initiated the physical violence and continued the assault after taking Nottingham to the ground. No criminal charges will be filed against Nottingham.

Local criminal defense attorney Gene Scott reviewed the footage for WJHL and said the shooting appeared justified.

Scott noted that both men had a lawful right to be at the business. However, Nottingham did not fire until he had been grabbed, thrown down and left on the ground without his prosthetic leg while the assault continued.

“It looks like he was doing what he had to do to defend himself,” Scott said.

A Fight With Permanent Consequences

Early reports described the incident as an argument over a parking spot. The completed investigation painted a different picture: a confrontation over an alleged disrespectful look that quickly became violent.

One man is dead. Another will have to live with taking a life. All of it unfolded over something that never needed to become physical.

The video also shows why complete investigations matter. The number of shots alone does not tell the whole story. Neither does the fact that one person was armed. Context—especially who started the violence and whether the threat was still happening—can determine whether a shooting is criminal or lawful self-defense.

Based on the footage and findings released so far, do you think the district attorney made the right call?

*** Buy and Sell on GunsAmerica! ***

https://gunsamerica.com/listings/search

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Dr Motown October 31, 2026, 5:21 am

    Probably the easiest example of a self-defense shooting…..punk attacks man with prosthetic leg, and victim reacts appropriately to stop the attack. So, what happened to the dead dude’s grandfather, who apparently said nothing while the idiot attacks a disabled man? Great family, eh?

  • Winston October 30, 2026, 1:41 pm

    Spaulding behaved just like those predatory, urban, ghetto rats do against that crippled white man.

  • LJ October 30, 2026, 8:39 am

    Totally justifiably. This young punk thought preying on an elderly handicapped man would be a piece of cake and bring him some level of twisted gratification and make him feel like a big man. Instead he got a gut full of hot lead. Good Riddance.

  • paul I'll call you what I want/1st Amendment October 29, 2026, 5:20 pm

    bet that bad guy won’t attack anymore handicapped people!