ITHACA 1911 for Sale
Browse Ithaca 1911 listings from verified sellers across the U.S. on GunsAmerica.
Quick Look
The Ithaca 1911 traces its roots to World War II, when Ithaca Gun Company produced over 300,000 1911A1 pistols for the U.S. military. Designed for rugged reliability and battlefield performance, the Ithaca 1911 maintains the classic feel and function of John Browning's original 1911 platform. While not as commercially common today, original models and authentic reproductions remain popular with collectors, reenactors, and 1911 purists.
Why It's a Top Choice
- Period-authentic WWII-era 1911A1 build and markings
- All-steel construction ensures durability and recoil control
- Respected for historical value in military collections
- Single-action trigger with crisp, clean break
- Compatible with standard 1911 parts for easy servicing
Key Variants
Ithaca 1911A1
Original GI-issued pistol made for the U.S. military during WWII with authentic wartime features.
Ithaca Service Model 1911
Modern-day reproduction retaining traditional design with refined machining for civilian collectors and shooters.
Ithaca Custom 1911
High-grade custom builds aimed at target shooters appreciative of classic 1911 ergonomics.
Competitor Comparison
| Feature | Ithaca 1911 | Colt 1911 | Springfield Mil-Spec 1911 |
|---|---|---|---|
| MSRP | Varies (used & collector) | $799+ | $699+ |
| Capacity | 7+1 | 7+1 | 7+1 |
| Weight | ~39 oz | ~39 oz | ~39 oz |
| Optics-Ready | No | Some variants | No |
| Trigger Type | Single Action | Single Action | Single Action |
| Notable Pro | Valuable piece of history | Broadest aftermarket support | Affordable 1911 starter |
| Notable Con | Harder to find new | Higher price for collectors | Basic sights and controls |
Best Use Cases
- Military firearm collecting
- Historical reenactment
- Range practice with classic platforms
- Personal defense (within limitations)
- Heirloom ownership or restoration projects
FAQs
Can I use modern .45 ACP ammo in an Ithaca 1911?
Yes, standard-pressure .45 ACP is safe, but avoid +P loads in collectible originals.
What is the difference between the Ithaca 1911 and Colt 1911?
Functionally similar, but differ in manufacturer marks, finish, and minor GI-era tolerances.
How does the Ithaca 1911 perform today?
Reliable for range and light defense use, though lacking modern features like optics or rails.
Prefer nearby results? Toggle to search local listings.
Auto Ordnance 1911A1 (1911TCAC11N) Old G
$999.99
Tisas 1911 A1 Service 9mm (1911A139)
$599.99
TARGET, 1911,9MM,NIB
$1,195.00
Sign up for our newsletter
Frequently asked questions
What types of firearms does GunsAmerica offer online?
Are there any restrictions to buying legal firearms from GunsAmerica?
What are some of the best firearm companies available at GunsAmerica?
Can I sell my firearm to GunsAmerica?
How does GunsAmerica handle firearm shipping and transfers?
Who We Are
About
From the latest advancements in firearm technology to trusted essentials, GunsAmerica offers a comprehensive selection of gun accessories designed to enhance performance, reliability, and safety. Whether you need precision optics, durable stocks, high-capacity magazines, suppressors, or muzzle devices, our marketplace provides everything required to maintain, upgrade, and customize your firearms. We feature products from leading manufacturers, ensuring superior quality and compatibility across all firearm platforms. Our extensive inventory is built to support every shooter’s needs, from tactical applications and competitive shooting to hunting and everyday carry. At GunsAmerica, we are committed to delivering a seamless, secure shopping experience with competitive pricing, making it easier than ever to find the right accessories to optimize your firearms for any mission or environment.