44-40 for Sale
Browse 44-40 listings from verified sellers across the U.S. on GunsAmerica.
Quick Look
Originally introduced in 1873 by Winchester alongside the Model 1873 rifle, the .44-40 Winchester became a staple Old West cartridge. Designed for both rifles and revolvers, it offered shooters a versatile load with consistent stopping power. Today, it remains popular among cowboy action shooters and historical firearm collectors.
Why It's a Top Choice
- Classic chambering for cowboy action competition
- Used in iconic lever-action rifles and revolvers
- Mild recoil with respectable terminal performance
- Reload-friendly bottle-necked case
- Widespread availability in historical firearm reproductions
Key Variants
Uberti 1873 .44-40
Faithful reproduction of the original Winchester, ideal for cowboy action events.
Cimarron Frontier .44-40
Single-action revolver true to 19th-century styling, perfect for reenactments and collection.
Winchester 1892 .44-40
Lightweight lever-action rifle with improved strength over earlier Winchester models.
Competitor Comparison Table
| Feature | .44-40 | .45 Colt | .38 Special |
|---|---|---|---|
| MSRP | Varies by firearm | Varies by firearm | Typically lower |
| Capacity / Size | 6-10 rounds | 6-10 rounds | 6+ rounds |
| Weight | Medium-heavy | Medium | Light to medium |
| Optics-Ready | Rare in classic builds | Limited options | More custom platforms |
| Trigger Type | Single-action / lever | Single-action | DA/SA or single-action |
| Notable Pro | Dual-use in rifle and handgun | Widely available loads | Mild recoil, high availability |
| Notable Con | Less modern firearm selection | Higher recoil than .38 | Less stopping power |
Best Use Cases
- Cowboy action shooting
- Western-era firearm collecting
- Historical reenactments
- Ranch carry (lever rifle)
- Range training with low recoil
FAQs
What is the difference between .44-40 and .44 Magnum?
The .44-40 is an older, lower-pressure cartridge; .44 Magnum is more powerful and modern.
Can I shoot .44-40 in a .44 Magnum revolver?
No. The cartridges are not interchangeable due to case shape, pressure, and chamber dimensions.
How does the .44-40 perform for cowboy action shooting?
It's a top choice due to low recoil, historical accuracy, and wide availability in replica firearms.
Prefer nearby results? Toggle to search local listings.
1873/Deluxe/Sporting, 44-40,NIB
$2,395.00
4309 CATTLEMAN ,NM IMPROVED , 44-40
$529.00
Sign up for our newsletter
Frequently asked questions
What types of firearms does GunsAmerica offer online?
Are there any restrictions to buying legal firearms from GunsAmerica?
What are some of the best firearm companies available at GunsAmerica?
Can I sell my firearm to GunsAmerica?
How does GunsAmerica handle firearm shipping and transfers?
Who We Are
About
From the latest advancements in firearm technology to trusted essentials, GunsAmerica offers a comprehensive selection of gun accessories designed to enhance performance, reliability, and safety. Whether you need precision optics, durable stocks, high-capacity magazines, suppressors, or muzzle devices, our marketplace provides everything required to maintain, upgrade, and customize your firearms. We feature products from leading manufacturers, ensuring superior quality and compatibility across all firearm platforms. Our extensive inventory is built to support every shooter’s needs, from tactical applications and competitive shooting to hunting and everyday carry. At GunsAmerica, we are committed to delivering a seamless, secure shopping experience with competitive pricing, making it easier than ever to find the right accessories to optimize your firearms for any mission or environment.


